Insights
Cheapest hotels

Shelter Island 4-star Hotels

Compare rates for 4-star hotels in Shelter Island, NY from hundreds of popular travel sites on HotelsCombined.

...and more

Learn why travelers love HotelsCombined

Compare hotel ratings collected from thousands of user reviews.

One search gives you accurate pricing on affordable hotels.

Customize your results by hotel chain, amenities, price and more.

Search for hotels as many times as you want – for free.

Travel insights for hotels in Shelter Island

Use our HotelsCombined data-powered tips to help you find your next hotel in Shelter Island.

What is the cheapest day to stay in a hotel in Shelter Island?

The cheapest day to stay in Shelter Island is Friday ($327). On the other hand, travelers can expect to pay the most on Thursday, when the average nightly price is $864.

Find deals

Cheapest 4-star hotels in Shelter Island

Discover affordable 4-star hotels in Shelter Island that provide a quality experience without breaking the bank. 4-star hotels in Shelter Island can be found for as low as $230 per night. Price data was last updated on April 2, 2026
These are the lowest-priced 4-star hotels our users have recently found in Shelter Island. Prices may vary based on dates selected and hotel location.
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States
1.3 mi from city centre
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$230
Avg. per night
View Deal

Other star-rated hotels in Shelter Island

Hotels that are booked the most in each class receive the “Most popular” badge. Hotels with the “Best value” have the most attractive prices based on their popularity. Price data was last updated on April 2, 2026.
Not set on a 4-star hotel? We’ve got plenty of other options for you to choose from. These are the most popular and best value properties in Shelter Island based on hotel class.
3 stars
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States
$803
View Deal
2 stars and under
House on Chase Creek
House on Chase Creek

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States
$140
View Deal

Other accommodations in Shelter Island

Find deals on places to stay in Shelter Island that are not hotels. These are just a few of the most popular hostels and vacation rentals in the area. Pricing information was last updated on April 2, 2026.
Looking for something less traditional for your stay? Find the perfect hostel or vacation rental for your trip in Shelter Island.
House on Chase Creek
House on Chase Creek

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States
1.3 mi from city centre
Free Wi-Fi
Air Conditioning
$140
Avg. per night
View Deal
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States
1.3 mi from city centre
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$230
Avg. per night
View Deal

Facts about 4-star hotels in Shelter Island

Find useful tips and insights about 4-star hotels in Shelter Island to help you make the most of your experience. FAQs were last updated on April 2, 2026.

  • What is the cheapest 4-star hotel in Shelter Island?

    Shelter Island House is the cheapest 4-star hotel in Shelter Island, where prices start as low as $230 per night.

  • What is the best 4-star hotel in Shelter Island?

    In Shelter Island, the best 4-star hotel is Shelter Island House, renowned for its 8.9 user rating and an average price of $440 per night.

Stay elsewhere in Shelter Island

Consider these popular 3-star hotels in Shelter Island

Stay at one of these Shelter Island 3-star hotels that users have found on HotelsCombined.
Sunset Beach