Sunset Beach Hotel

Hotel
3 stars
35 Shore Road, 11965, Shelter Island, New York, United States
Shelter Island, NY
+1 631 749 2001
7.7
Good
based on 7 reviews
7 verified ratings
Sun 7/19
-
Mon 7/20
2 guests, 1 room
Deals from
$603
/Cheapest rate per night
Provider
Nightly total
$603
$799
$802
Bedroom
Restaurant
Outdoors view
Building
Restaurant
Building
Building
Room amenity
Living room
Living room
Bedroom
Bedroom
Building
Bedroom
Bedroom
Bathroom
Photos of Sunset Beach Hotel
View a collection of 16 photos showcasing the rooms, amenities, and facilities of Sunset Beach Hotel to help you visualize your stay. Photos for this property were last updated on July 12, 2026.
Rooms
About
Reviews
Similar hotels
Location
FAQ

Best deals for Sunset Beach Hotel

Explore the most appealing deals available for Sunset Beach Hotel, ensuring you get the best value for your stay. Properties were last updated on July 12, 2026.
Sun 7/19
-
Mon 7/20
Double room
Double room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$799
nightly with fees
Superior room
Superior room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$802
nightly with fees
King room
King room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$603
nightly with fees
*Total includes estimated local taxes & fees payable on check out.
Prices are based on 1 night, including fees but not including taxes.
Best priceguarantee

About Sunset Beach Hotel

Discover essential information, amenities, and features of Sunset Beach Hotel, providing insights into what to expect during your stay. Information on this property was last updated on July 12, 2026.
A seaside hideaway nestled on the sands of Shelter Island Sound on the eastern end of Long Island, New York. With only twenty guest rooms, and a beachfront restaurant and bar, Sunset Beach offers the ...

Good to Know

Check-in time3:00 PM
Check-out time11:00 AM
Payment & CancellationPolicies vary by room type and provider.
Front desk number+1 631 749 2001

Perks and amenities at Sunset Beach Hotel

A comprehensive list of on-site, in-building, and in-room amenities you’ll find at Sunset Beach Hotel
  • Private beach
  • Room service
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Cable or satellite TV
  • Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
  • Laundry service
  • Babysitting or child care
  • Air-conditioned
  • Minibar

Basics

  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Air-conditioned

Media and entertainment

  • Cable or satellite TV

Accessibility and suitability

  • Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.

Outdoor

  • Private beach

Laundry

  • Laundry service

Dining

  • Minibar

Services and conveniences

  • Room service

Family friendly

  • Babysitting or child care

Reviews for Sunset Beach Hotel

Read firsthand reviews and testimonials from guests who have stayed at Sunset Beach Hotel, providing insights into their experiences. Travelers have left 7 reviews of Sunset Beach Hotel to date. Review data was last updated on July 12, 2026.
7.7
Good
7 verified ratings
Wonderful
1
Very good
1
Good
3
Okay
2
Fair
0
Mediocre
0
Poor
0
Sort by:Most recent

Filters

All filters

Filters

Review rating
Traveler type
Time of year

Score by provider

Hotels similar to Sunset Beach Hotel

Discover other properties in Shelter Island that offer a similar experience and ambiance to Sunset Beach Hotel. In total, there are 77 hotels serving travelers in Shelter Island. Price data was last updated on July 12, 2026.

Cheap Shelter Island hotels

These hotels are among the lowest-priced properties for travelers in Shelter Island. Currently, the lowest price for a hotel in Shelter Island is $230. The cheapest hotel is Shelter Island House priced at $230. Price data was last updated on July 12, 2026.
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States
1.3 mi from city centre
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$230
Avg. per night
View Deal
House on Chase Creek
House on Chase Creek

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States
1.3 mi from city centre
Free Wi-Fi
Air Conditioning
$281
Avg. per night
View Deal
See cheapest hotels in Shelter Island

Explore Shelter Island

Sunset Beach Hotel is located at 35 Shore Road in the neighborhood of Shelter Island. Popular landmark data was lasted updated on July 12, 2026.
Sunset Beach Hotel location: 35 Shore Road

Most Popular Landmarks

  • Manhanset Chapel1.6 mi
  • James Havens Homestead1.9 mi
  • Havens House1.9 mi
  • Mashomack Preserve2.8 mi

FAQs when booking at Sunset Beach Hotel

Find answers to commonly asked questions regarding reservations, amenities, policies, and more when booking a stay at Sunset Beach Hotel. FAQs were last updated on July 12, 2026.

  • Is pricing at Sunset Beach Hotel comparable to 3 star hotels in Shelter Island?

    Nightly rates at Sunset Beach Hotel will generally be 8% cheaper than the average 3-stars hotel in Shelter Island. When staying at Sunset Beach Hotel, you should be prepared to pay about $756/night, which is considered to be a good deal in Shelter Island for a 3-stars hotel.

  • How close is Sunset Beach Hotel to the nearest airport, Islip Long Island Airport?

    At 42.9 mi away, Islip Long Island Airport is the closest airport to Sunset Beach Hotel. The average expected drive time from Sunset Beach Hotel to Islip Long Island Airport is 1h 25m. It’s a good idea to research traffic trends between your hotel and the airport.

  • Is Sunset Beach Hotel considered pet-friendly?

    Guests are allowed to bring house pets to Sunset Beach Hotel during their stay.

  • What is the Sunset Beach Hotel phone number?

    For questions about Sunset Beach Hotel and your reservation, contact the front desk directly at +1 631 749 2001.

  • Does Sunset Beach Hotel have Wi-Fi available?

    Yes, Sunset Beach Hotel has Wi-Fi available to hotel guests.

  • What is the check-out time at Sunset Beach Hotel?

    Sunset Beach Hotel has a normal check-in time of after 3:00 PM, and check-out time of before 11:00 AM.

  • How much does it cost to stay at Sunset Beach Hotel, Shelter Island?

    Prices at Sunset Beach Hotel will vary depending on when you plan to stay and what room type you require. The average nightly room price recently has been $756, though some users have found rates as low as $501. To see prices for your dates, enter them in the form above.

  • Does Sunset Beach Hotel have a laundry service?

    Yes, there are laundry services usually available at Sunset Beach Hotel, Shelter Island.

  • What is the cheapest day to check into Sunset Beach Hotel?

    Consider checking into Sunset Beach Hotel on Monday, when the nightly price is typically at its lowest (average nightly rate of $603).

See more FAQs

Millions of Reviews

Real ratings and reviews from millions of guests, just like yourself. Book your perfect stay with confidence!

Best Hotel Deals

HotelsCombined sources over 3 million hotels and properties and compiles them in one place so you can compare the ideal accommodation.

Free Cancellation

Plans change — we get it. And that’s why you can search and book hotels and accommodations on HotelsCombined from agencies that offer free cancellation

Find better results for your stay in Sunset Beach Hotel