How much does a vacation rental in Fire Island cost?

$917 per night is how much a vacation rental in Fire Island costs, on average. $165 per night was the cheapest price recently found by our users, though anything for $890 per night or less is a good deal. Keep in mind that Fire Island vacation rental prices fluctuate throughout the year: the most expensive month to book is July, and the cheapest time to book is August.

Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Search and compare Fire Island, NY vacation rentals from hundreds of travel sites on HotelsCombined and save.

Travel insights for vacation rentals in Fire Island

Use our HotelsCombined data-powered tips to help you find your next vacation rental in Fire Island.

What is the cheapest day to stay in a vacation rental in Fire Island?

The cheapest day to stay in Fire Island is Monday ($486). On the other hand, travelers can expect to pay the most on Sunday, when the average nightly price is $2,371.

Where to stay in Fire Island

Explore different neighborhoods and areas within Fire Island to find the perfect location for your stay. Map data was last updated on November 13, 2025.

Use the map to find vacation rentals in Fire Island that are close to the points of interest you'll be frequenting. As an added benefit, users can click a vacation rental they're interesting in to find helpful information and deals for that vacation rental.

Facts about staying in Fire Island

Find useful tips and insights about staying in Fire Island to help you make the most of your experience. FAQs were last updated on November 13, 2025.

How much does a vacation rental in Fire Island cost?

Find better results for your stay in Fire Island

Explore these cities in New York

Looking to explore New York during your trip? These are other popular cities nearby that HotelsCombined users visit